Friday, October 26, 2007

Welcome to SEC Bias

Welcome to South-East Coast Bias. Let me just get this out the way: The SEC is the best conference in the country. Football in particular. The Big Ten? Fuck you. ACC? Eat a dick. PAC 10? Bunch of hippies.

OK - so that's coming on a little strong. But realistically speaking, I think history bares out the truth that the SEC is the top conference in college football. This season is no different. Currently seven teams are ranked in the AP Top 25, including four in the top 15. No other conference has more than four in the top 25.


All that aside, I think I need to point out the East Coast Bias that is present in today's sports coverage. Not a novel concept, I know, but since when does Matt Ryan become a Heisman contender? In ESPN.com's latest Heisman poll, Matt Ryan ranks second. Sure, the first and third ranked contenders are SEC quarterbacks, but it boggles my mind that Matt Ryan would even be under consideration. Up until his comeback win against VaTech, which mind you occurred after ESPN's latest poll, what had he done? His team is ranked second and he is the quarterback. Big whoop. That's how Jason White and Chris Weinke won the Heisman. Is that really what we want?

And yes, I'm still angry that Charles Woodson won the Heisman instead of Peyton Manning.

So in this column (column sounds more official than blog) I'll be mostly writing about football, with some occasional NBA and MLB observations. I may even foray into Formula One, soccer, and other European-type sports. I'll also occasionally write about random things that piss me off, whether it's work-related (I do have a real job), random annoying assholes, or petty complaints about Pop Culture. I should probably also point out that my favorite teams are the Tennessee Volunteers, Chicago Bears and Atlanta Braves. If I had to pick an NBA team, I'd go with the Pistons. There is a logic here, which I'll explain at a later date, but no, I'm not a bandwagon fan. If I was, I'm sure I'd be a fan of USC, the Red Sox and the Patriots. But I'm not. Because bandwagon fans suck.

Anyhow, on to the meat of my first subject

I felt that, as a college football aficionado, it was important for me to generate my own Top 25. My criteria may differ slightly from that of the fine individuals who submit ballots for the AP, Harris Poll, etc, in that I consider potential as well as current performance. This is due to the fact that many teams (Pac-10 and Big Ten in particular) have yet to get into the heart of their schedules. For example, BC may be 8-0, but did they really deserve to be #2 just because they have gone the season without losing a game?

1 – LSU (7-1)
Key Wins: Va Tech (48-7), Florida (28-24), Auburn (30-24)
Loss(es): @ Kentucky (43-37)
LSU has shown that they are the most dominant team in college football right now, despite the 3OT loss to Kentucky. An upcoming trip to Tuscaloosa will give the Tigers a chance to re-establish themselves and start looking forward to an SEC Title re-match with Florida.
2 – Ohio State (8-0)
Key Wins: @ Purdue 23-7
Loss(es): None
Ohio State has not done anything to prevent them from attaining the number one ranking, but until they play (and beat) a top opponent, I cannot rank them higher than a team that has already defeated three top 15 opponents. Unfortunately, tough tests appear to be few and far between in this year’s Big Ten.
3 – Oregon (6-1)
Key Wins: @ Michigan (39-7), Fresno State (52-21)
Loss(es): Cal (31-24)
The early win against Michigan is looking better and better as the Wolverines roll through the Big Ten, and the Ducks will have two opportunities to put their own exclamation point on a surprising run with consecutive home games against USC and Arizona State.
4 – Oklahoma (7-1)
Key Wins: @ Texas (28-21), @ Missouri (41-31)
Loss(es): @ Colorado (27-24)
Sam Bradford has led a resurgence in the Sooners’ passing game, but Oklahoma will need to avoid mental lapses like last week’s uninspired effort against Iowa State
to remain in the top 5.
5 – Florida (5-2)
Key Wins: Tennessee (59-20), @ Kentucky (45-37)
Loss(es): Auburn (20-17), @ LSU (28-24)
Two tough losses, but with the way Tim Tebow and company are playing, I have a hard time believing that any of the remaining one-loss and undefeated teams could knock off the Gators. If Tebow continues playing the way he has so far, he'll be hearing plenty more "Fuck You Te-Bow" chants at opposing stadiums.
6 – ASU (7-0)
Key Wins: Colorado (33-14)
Loss(es): None
Arizona State has not faced a strong challenger this season, but the Sun Devils put their undefeated season to the test starting this week with a brutal PAC-10 run, including Cal, Oregon, @UCLA, and USC.
7 – USF (6-1)
Key Wins: @ Auburn (26-23), W Virginia (21-13)
Loss(es): @ Rutgers (30-27)
USF has shown enough with wins over SEC power Auburn and Big East contender West Virginia to prove that they deserve a top ten ranking. Their Big East schedule is set up for a possible 11-1 finish.
8 – Missouri (6-1)
Key Wins: Illinois (40-34), Nebraska (41-6), Texas Tech (41-10)
Loss(es): @ Oklahoma (31-41)
Like Oregon, Missouri is getting some mileage out of an early season victory over a Big Ten opponent. The Tigers have rolled through their Big 12 challengers, with the exception of Oklahoma. If Kansas continues to roll, the end-of-season matchup with the Jayhawks could prove interesting.
9 – BC (8-0)
Key Wins: @ Georgia Tech (24-10), VT (14-10)
Loss(es): None
With a win over Virginia Tech, BC has proven that it deserves to be undefeated. However, BC’s credentials aren’t significantly more impressive than ASU, or even Kansas, so I can’t match the #2 AP ranking until BC proves it can go the distance.
10 – WVU (6-1)
Key Wins: None
Loss(es): USF (13-21)
The Mountaineers lack a signature win, but could get the closest thing to it with a win at Rutgers this weekend.
11 – Kentucky (6-2)
Key Wins: Louisville (40-34), LSU (43-37)
Loss(es): @ South Carolina (38-23), Florida (45-37)
Kentucky finally fells Louisville, who then turns around and lies down on its season. With Andre Woodson leading the charge, Kentucky looks like a legitimate threat. A porous defense (25 or more points allowed in five games) could thwart any further improvement in the Wildcats ranking.
12 – Kansas (7-0)
Key Wins: @Kansas St (30-24), @ Colorado (19-14)
Loss(es): None
Kansas has dominated its lesser opponents and knocked off its first two Big 12 challenges. The Jayhawks host Missouri looms in the season finale.
13 – USC (6-1)
Key Wins: @ Nebraska (49-31)
Loss(es): Stanford (23-24)
USC has done little to prove that it deserved the almost universal assumption that a National Championship was a mere formality. As with the other PAC-10 teams, the next few weeks will sort out the pretenders from the contenders. Perhaps USC will still have a chance to redeem themselves after an inexplicable loss to the Cardinal.
14 – VT (6-2)
Key Wins: @ Clemson (41-23)
Loss(es): @ LSU (7-48), @ BC (10-14)
VT let an away win over BC slip through its fingers, but if the Hokies can run the table, they will set up a potential rematch with BC in the ACC Championship. You can bet that VT would love a second chance at Boston College.
15 – Auburn (5-3)
Key Wins: Kansas State (23-13), Florida (20-17)
Loss(es): USF (23-26), Miss St (14-19), @ LSU (24-30)
Auburn may have three losses, but it’s tough to be too hard on them given how close each of those losses was. The win over Florida came at just the right time for this program, thrusting them back into the SEC title hunt.
16 – Cal (5-2)
Key Wins: Tennessee (45-31), @ Oregon (31-24)
Loss(es): Oregon St (28-31), UCLA (21-30)
A promising season appears to have derailed as the Golden Bears have suffered two straight defeats. With the return of talented QB Nate Longshore, Cal will look to rebound against undefe
ated Arizona State.
17 – Michigan (6-2)
Key Wins: Penn State (14-9), Purdue (48-21), @ Illinois (27-17)
Loss(es): App St (32-34), Oregon (7-39)
Either the Big Ten is really lousy, or Appalachian State was a fluke loss. Mike Hart has carried this team all season, and the Wolverines will need him back and healthy if they hope to contend for the Big Ten title. All eyes are on 11/17, when the Buckeyes come into town. That game will likely decide the Big Ten championship.
18 – South Carolina (6-2)
Key Wins: @ Georgia (16-12), Kentucky (38-23)
Loss(es): @ LSU (16-28), @ Vanderbilt (6-17)
What gives? South Carolina knocks off SEC East rivals Kentucky and Georgia, and then falls to Vanderbilt. This week’s matchup against Tennessee will help prove whether Spurrier-led South Carolina has finally made the leap to being a legitimate SEC contender.
19 – Alabama (6-2)
Key Wins: Tennessee (41-17)
Loss(es): Georgia (23-26), @ FSU (14-21)
Nick Saban welcomes his former employer, LSU, into Tuscaloosa this weekend, as the Crimson Tide looks to move into a three-way tie for first place in the SEC West. Up until the thumping of the Vols, Alabama had not looked particularly impressive.
20 – Texas (5-2)
Key Wins: None
Loss(es): Kansas State (21-41), Oklahoma (21-28)
It’s hard to tell if Texas even belongs in the top 25. Texas has lost to the only two decent teams it has played and has looked sluggish in its victories. Upcoming games against rivals Nebraska, Texas A&M and Texas Tech will help show what kind of team the Longhorns are fielding this year.
21 – Virginia (7-1)
Key Wins: U Conn (17-16), Georgia Tech (28-23)
Loss(es): @ Wyoming (3-23)
Aside from the opening loss to Wyoming, Virginia has led a charmed life, winning four games by a total of six points. Virginia could very well be headed to the ACC Championship as the Coastal division representative.
22 – Rutgers (5-2)
Key Wins: South Florida (30-27)
Loss(es): Maryland (24-34), Cincinnati (23-28)
With Ray Rice running strong, Rutgers is certainly capable of surprising a few teams. One of those teams might be West Virginia, who visits New Jersey this weekend.
23 – Penn St (6-2)
Key Wins: Wisconsin (38-7)
Loss(es): @ Michigan (9-14), @ Illinois (20-27)
Penn State appears to be peaking offensively at just the right time: Ohio State comes into town this weekend. Penn State has put up 27 or more points in its last three games, but will likely have a tough time moving the ball against OSU.
24 – Georgia (5-2)
Key Wins: Oklahoma St (35-14), Alabama (26-23)
Loss(es): South Carolina (12-16), @ Tennessee (14-35)
Georgia has struggled with consistency this year. The OT win over Alabama was a great win for the program and it looked like Matt Stafford might have made “The Leap” but the ‘Dawgs came crashing down with a blowout loss at Neyland Stadium.
25 – Hawaii (7-0)
Key Wins: None
Loss(es): None
Winning games is tough, and Hawaii has certainly shown that with a couple of close games against mediocre opponents. But you have to give them credit for not slipping up yet. Until Hawaii loses a game, they will stay in my top 25. But don’t expect them to beat both Fresno State and Boise State.

Others given consideration:
Clemson, Wake Forest, Georgia Tech, Kansas State, Illinois, UCLA

This should be an excellent weekend for college football, with five matchups between Top 25 teams. In addition, several important conference games will serve to clear up space at the top of each conference. Florida at Georgia, OSU at Penn State, USC at Oregon - should all be great games.

If it wasn't for Halloween parties, I'd be up late watching the Tennessee-South Carolina tilt, but instead I'll have to settle for working on my Tony Montana accent and slamming Heinekens and Jaeger Bombs.

1 comment:

Average at Best said...

Good post.

I especially like how you tried to downplay your bandwagon fan-dom. I mean all you do is pick the winning teams from places you've lived. Except the Bears. That might be a pure bandwagon move. A respectable one, but still one nonetheless.

I mean, seriously, you lived in Atlanta and only like the Braves? Fine, but what happened to the Falcons and Hawks. Did I just ask that?

You live in Detroit, but no Lions? Shit, did I just ask that too? I'm surprised you don't like the Tigers. And picking the Pistons is real bandwagon.

You lived near Cincinatti and...wait never mind. Good non choice. I guess there is a twisted logic in all this somewhere. You might need a post to explain this.

Other than that, good post and analysis of college football. Anything that punches Ohio St. in the balls is good by me.